Yeah, there’s a clear preference for size-only over nw-only, but it’s by no means a consensus, especially considering the “both” votes.
It’s a limited sample, but this matches up with my own observations over the years. The claim that “everybody agrees size is the real measure” falls short.
To say it another way: just barely half of the polled players think size is the true measure, which doesn’t support the idea of a size win being the “real” win.